About Us

Finger Lakes Cookie Co. was founded by Lori Bush in 2016 to continue the legacy of her parents, Tom and Lois Bush,and their support for the Livingston/Wyoming ARC program. ARC and its wonderful staff are dedicated to providing numerous resources required by developmentally disabled individuals including housing and employment.   We are indebted to ARC for assisting our family with our sister, Linda’s, needs over the last 35 years.

The Finger Lakes Cookie Co. mission is four fold:

1.To create a multitude of unique gourmet cookies that appeal to everyone’s sense of flavor.    A) Uniquely created cookies using local wines, local coffees, and local brews.  B)Traditional cookies that are made with the finest ingredients including Ghirardelli chocolate, local butter, local eggs, and unique baking chip.

2. To support the growth of our community and schools through unique partnerships.

3.  To eventually become an employer providing unique internships and job opportunities for SUNY Geneseo students, Geneseo Central School students, and developmentally disabled adults.

4.  To become the premier cookie company recognized throughout the Upstate New York/Finger Lakes area for supporting our communities growth… through Hope and Partnerships our community grows!

Our cookies can be found for sale at:

Finger Lakes Cookie Co.

94 Main St, Ste 101

Geneseo, NY 14454

Park on Main St and take a short stroll down School St or Bank St.   On the back side of Notebook Tek building.

Hours:   Sundays & Mondays: Closed

Tuesday through Friday: 12-8pm
Saturday: 12-4pm

Deer Run Winery Tastings and Concert Series

3772 W Lake Rd

Geneseo, NY 14454

Geneseo Central School Sports Booster Athletic Events

4050 Avon Rd

Geneseo, NY 14454

Jamison Wood-fire BBQ

State St, Caledonia, NY



Finger Lakes Cookie Company caters large group events including Weddings, Business staff meetings and events, and large parties.   Customization of orders is our specialty.   Choose between our regular-sized cookies or our very popular mini cookies.

This slideshow requires JavaScript.



For additional details regarding your special event, contact our event coordinator .

Phone: (585) 748-1886

Email:  fingerlakescookieco@yahoo.com