Welcome!

Located in the quaint village of Geneseo, NY, home of SUNY Geneseo, Finger Lakes Cookie Co. was created with a vision of bringing back the unique qualities of a small-town bakery.

We create old-fashioned cookies —like your grandma used to make…..thick, soft, chewy, and incredibly large.    All cookies are made with the finest ingredients:  Real butter, pure vanilla, local butter and eggs, and  Ghiradelli chocolate.

Day old cookies are donated to the local food pantry or Livingston/Wyoming ARC homes and 10% of all proceeds are donated to the Livingston/Wyoming ARC program.

       

Our Cookies            Holiday Gift Sets       Fundraising With Us

 

 

About Us

Finger Lakes Cookie Co was created to continue the legacy of Tom and Lois Bush and their support for the Livingston/Wyoming ARC program.  This organization and its wonderful staff are dedicated to providing all the resources a handicapped adult requires including housing and employment.   We are indebted to ARC for assisting our family over 35 years with the care of our handicapped sister, Linda.

Finger Lakes Cookie Co. mission is three fold:

  1. To provide old-fashioned cookies (like your grandmother made years ago) using the finest ingredients.  Our cookie products include individual cookies, cookie trays, customized cookies for events,  cookie cakes for birthdays, ice cream sandwiches created with homemade cookies, and other unique cookie products to the Finger Lakes area.  Because of our unique geographic location we are able to serve SUNY Geneseo students, numerous school systems within the Finger Lakes, and many small businesses in the Finger Lakes including wineries and eateries.
  2. To donate a portion of the proceeds to support the Livingston/Wyoming ARC program.
  3. To employ Livingston/Wyoming ARC clients to assist in the production of the cookies.

Our cookies can be found for sale at:

Finger Lakes Cookie Co

94 Main St, Ste 101

Geneseo, NY 14454

Park on Main St and take a short stroll down School St or Bank St.   On the back side of Notebook Tek building.

Hours:   Monday through Saturday:  11:30 a.m. to 8:00 p.m.

Sundays:  2:00 p.m. to 8:00 p.m.

 

 

Deer Run Winery Tastings and Concert Series

3772 W Lake Rd

Geneseo, NY 14454

 

Casa Larga Vineyards Tastings and Patio Parties

2287 Turk Hill Rd

Fairport, NY  14450

 

During athletic events at:

Geneseo Central School

4050 Avon Rd

Geneseo, NY 14454

 

 

Catering/Wholesale

Finger Lakes Cookie Company caters large group events including business meetings, parties, and weddings.   Customization of orders is our specialty.  Large orders are always discounted.

Platters.

This slideshow requires JavaScript.

Prices for Mix and Match (traditional and specialty cookies)

Baker’s dozen (13) ……………………………………………………..$18.00

Two Dozen ……………………………………………………….. …….$36.00

Three Dozen  ………………………………………………….. ……….$54.00

Four Dozen  …………………………………………………………….. $72.00

Five Dozen ……………………………………………………………….$90.00

Six Dozen ………………………………………………………………..$108.00

 

Mini cookies:

Baker’s dozen (13) ……………………………………………………..$6.00

Two dozen ……………………………………………………………….$12.00

Three dozen……………………………………………………………..$18.00

Four dozen ………………………………………………………………$24.00

Want to place a special order? Questions about our cookies? Reach out to us:

Phone: (585) 748-1886

Facebook: facebook.com/fingerlakescookieco

Instagram: fingerlakescookieco